C. Boyden Gray: Ho-hum on the Caspian

The Bush administration has finally named a senior diplomat to challenge Russia in the pipeline war in Europe. He is C. Boyden Gray, the Bush family friend and GOP partisan lawyer.

As O and G readers have read over the previous months, Russia and the West, particularly the U.S., have been in fierce competition to control the natural gas supply to Europe, and ultimately to influence the continent's politics. Under Vladimir Putin's determined, hands-on leadership, Russia has been far in the lead and, unless something changes fast, will win the contest.

Hence a push within some circles, including Senator Richard Lugar specifically and the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in general, for Washington to get serious by naming a prominent senior statesman to spearhead the U.S. effort. The first nominee was Thomas Pickering, but his personal finances turned out to be a conflict of interest. Then, someone suggested Bush family friend Donald Evans, the former Commerce secretary, but that also went nowhere.

Now the administration has settled on Gray, who was counsel to George H.W. Bush, and named as a recess appointment by President Bush as envoy to the European Union when the Senate refused to confirm him.

Gray comes from similar aristocratic stock as the Bushes -- with inherited wealth, his father was secretary of the Army under Harry S. Truman, and his grandfather was chairman of R.J. Reynolds Tobacco. He graduated from Harvard, and clerked under Supreme Court Chief Justice Earl Warren.

I'm perplexed. Is this the man to general the West's battle against one of the world's consummate players of brutal market economics, namely Vladimir Putin?

To find out whether I'm simply out of the loop, I took a sampling of some of the best-connected readers of O and G. As usual, this sampling will be anonymously sourced:

1. "Doesn't sound like the person we need to bring some coherency to our policy in that part of the world."

2. "(The Senate Foreign Relations Committee) pressed Condi hard to DO SOMETHING, so, [this is] more or less her saying ‘Get this off my plate!’ This was the political compromise. Politics, not grand strategy.”

3. "[Gray's] pluses -- close to the White House, maybe gravitas (but he is a pompous ass), smart guy. Minuses -- intensely partisan, loves to hector the EU, does not know energy, [does not speak] Russian. Bottom line -- not great but could be worse."

4. "Really lousy appointment. Can hardly think of anyone worse."

What's obvious is that no one of significance would accept the appointment. Which is why you have Rice simply adding new duties onto an existing envoy's portfolio. Which is also why the announcement was made in a one-paragraph statement issued with no fanfare.

In other words, this is a dull spearhead.